Marco’s New Yorker Crust vs. Original: A Delicious Comparison

In the lively and diverse realm of pizza, a timeless debate continues to simmer: the clash between Marco's New Yorker crust and the original version. With passionate devotees on both sides of the gastronomical spectrum, this culinary feud epitomizes the essence of preference and taste. Whether you hail from the concrete jungles of New York City or find solace in the traditional roots of Italy, these two variations offer distinct attributes that ignite the taste buds and ignite a fierce discussion. Embark on a flavorsome journey as we delve into the distinct qualities, historical roots, and cultural significance that define these two iterations of pizza perfection. Remember, in the realm of culinary opulence, the choice is yours to embrace the unrivaled chewy-crisp decadence of the New Yorker crust or the delicate and iconic flavors of the original.

What Makes NY Pizza Crust Different?

The crust of New York-style pizza is what sets it apart from other types of pizza. It’s known for being large, hand-tossed, and thin, making it easy to fold in half and eat on the go. The crust has a unique combination of thickness and crispiness along the edges, while remaining soft, thin, and pliable underneath the toppings.

One of the key factors that contribute to the special texture and flavor of New York pizza crust is the use of high-gluten bread flour. This flour has a higher protein content than regular all-purpose flour, resulting in a chewier and sturdier crust that can hold up to the weight of the toppings. It also gives the crust a distinct, slightly nutty flavor that’s beloved by pizza enthusiasts.

Another element that plays a part in the crusts character is the tap water used in New York City. The minerals present in the citys water supply are believed to enhance the dough, giving it a unique texture and flavor. While the exact role of the water is still debated, many believe that it helps create a lighter, airier crust and contributes to the overall deliciousness of New York-style pizza.

The process of making the crust is also crucial to achieving the desired result. The dough is typically hand-tossed, meaning it’s stretched and spun in the air to create a thin and even base. This technique allows for better heat distribution during baking, resulting in a crispy yet tender crust. The dough is often left to rise for a longer period of time to develop more flavor and texture before being shaped into the iconic thin crust.

Now that we’ve established that New York pizza is known for it’s thin crust, it’s time to delve into the other essential elements that make this iconic style of pizza so beloved. From the toppings to the cheese and sauce, each aspect plays a crucial role in creating the perfect slice. So, let’s explore the world of New York pizza and uncover what sets it apart from it’s counterparts.

Is New York Pizza Thin or Thick Crust?

New York pizza, a culinary icon in the bustling streets of the Big Apple, is renowned for it’s unmistakably thin crust. The crust is the very foundation upon which New York pizzas fame is built, drawing inspiration from it’s Neapolitan origins. A key characteristic of this beloved pizza style is it’s incredibly thin, delicate crust, which is a mere fraction of an inch in thickness. As you savor each mouthwatering bite, youll notice that the crust gradually thickens as it approaches the outer rim, creating a perfect balance of textures.

One distinctive feature to look out for in a genuine New York pizza crust is the presence of bubbles. These glorious air pockets, affectionately referred to as “holes,” contribute to the crusts textural complexity and enhance the overall eating experience. The bubbles are most prominent in the edge area, adding a delightful visual and tactile element to each slice.

The crust should measure less than one-fourth of an inch until it nears the edge, where it gains a slightly thicker consistency for structural support. Remarkable hole structure, achieved through expert dough stretching techniques, enhances the crusts texture and appeal.

Source: New York–style pizza


While the original crust maintains it’s traditional appeal and loyal following, Marco's New Yorker crust brings a modern twist to the table with it’s larger size and thicker texture. Both options have their distinct qualities and charm, offering a delightful experience for pizza lovers. So, whether you opt for the classic simplicity or the bold innovation, one thing is for sure – pizza remains a universally loved indulgence that unites people across cultures and generations.

Scroll to Top